Compassionate care for people with dementia
Dr. Liora was waiting in the clinic when she noticed Nurit, a 75-year-old woman with mid-stage dementia, and her daughter Yael accompanying her. Nurit seemed confused and restless, asking repeatedly when they were coming home. Yael, who looked very tired, gently took her hand and reassured her: "Mom, we'll be done soon."
When they entered the office, Dr. Liora got down to Nurit's eye level, smiled, and said softly: "Hello Nurit, I'm Liora. We're here to make sure you're feeling good." Despite her concerns, Nurit began to relax. Yael breathed a sigh of relief when she saw that her mother was cooperating with the examination.
This situation, which occurs in various versions in many clinics and hospitals, highlights how important it is for doctors to be sensitive, compassionate, and empathetic toward patients with dementia— and their family caregivers. Here are some practical recommendations, based on current research, for improving communication and care for patients with mid- and late-stage dementia, and for supporting their families.
Communicating with a patient with dementia – rules and recommended behaviors
Effective and compassionate communication with a person living with dementia is a cornerstone of treatment. Research shows that as dementia progresses, the ability to express and speak decreases, and feelings of frustration and anxiety may arise due to difficulty expressing needs [1]. However, even in advanced stages, many patients retain the ability to communicate – especially through non-verbal channels [1]. Here are some highlights of effective communication based on research findings:
- Patience, listening and giving time to respond: Be patient and give the patient time to process and respond. Avoid interrupting. If the patient is struggling or frustrated, allow a tolerable break and try again later. Qualitative research has found that such a patient approach – including postponing the task to a later time in the event of resistance – has been shown to be helpful in dealing with restless patients [2]. The “they won’t resist if we don’t insist” approach illustrates the need to approach gently, not forcefully, and try again later.
- Body language and warm eye contact: Create Eye contact Be direct, smile, and communicate at eye level. Your body language conveys an important message—sometimes more than words. A calm, warm, and respectful tone of voice has a positive effect on the patient, who, even if they don’t understand all the words, will pick up on the tone [3]. Studies show that facial expressions, a gentle touch on the hand or shoulder, and calm body movements can convey a sense of reassurance and understanding when words alone are not enough [1].
- Simple speech, short, slow sentences: Communicate in clear, simple language. Use short sentences that focus on one idea at a time, and avoid overly abstract or medical terms. Speak slowly and in a calm voice., to allow the patient to follow along. A systematic review has found that techniques such as using short sentences and removing distractions (e.g., turning off the TV in the background) improve comprehension in people with dementia [1]. Clear instructions and breaking down tasks into small steps also help reduce anxiety and resistance from the patient [2]. For example, instead of saying all at once, “Let’s do a full physical examination,” try breaking it down into tasks: “Now we’ll check blood pressure… great, and now we’ll listen to the heart” – an approach that has been shown to reduce resistance [2].
- Support memory and communication with external cues: To help a patient who has difficulty finding words or remembering, use In non-verbal cues. You can point, demonstrate actions (e.g., point to a glass of water when asked if they are thirsty), or use familiar pictures and objects. Memory aids such as a photo album from the past or flashcards can stimulate conversation and help connect the patient to their environment [1]. Simple technologies, such as using pictures of actions when explaining, have been found to improve understanding and communication in patients with moderate dementia [1]. Also Calling out the patient's name At the beginning of each address, it helps to get his attention in a respectful manner [2].
- Validating emotions and avoiding head-on confrontation: If the patient expresses confusion or says something that is not consistent with reality (for example, is in the wrong time or place), show understanding for their feelings instead of arguing about the facts. Validate the feelings – For example, replying “I understand you miss home, it’s really hard to be here” when the patient wants to leave, instead of telling them “You’re wrong, you’re in the hospital now.” Technique of "Indirect correction" found effective: Instead of correcting the patient, repeat or slightly modify what they said to continue the conversation without causing frustration [2]. In one study, we gave the example of a patient who said “We are in Spain now” – the interviewer responded with “Really in Spain?” instead of directly correcting [2]. This approach keeps the conversation flowing smoothly and avoids unnecessary confrontation. Subtle humor It can also help: It is permissible to smile warmly or even laugh softly with the patient (not at him) to relieve tension and create closeness, as experienced therapists have noted [1].
- Adapting the physical environment: Pay attention to the environment in which communication takes place. Noise, commotion, or a foreign environment can be confusing and stressful for a person with dementia, whereas a familiar, quiet environment can create a sense of security and encourage collaboration [1]. Try to conduct interviews and examinations in a calm room, with appropriate lighting and comfort. A recent review highlighted that reducing background noise and creating a private space for sensitive conversation supports better communication [2]. If additional family members or staff are present, this should be managed carefully: a supportive presence (e.g. a smile or a family member’s hand-holding) can help, but sometimes excessive intervention by a companion can drown out the patient’s voice [1]. Decide who will speak when, so that the patient does not feel overwhelmed.
To conclude this section, remember that each person with dementia is a whole world – personalize your approach . Get to know their personal history, hobbies and past: this information can give you positive conversation topics (for example, reminding the patient that he was a literature teacher about his students – something that enlightens him) and avoid unfortunate triggers [2]. Such a personal approach, recognizing the unique value of the individual, is the core of respectful care.
An empathetic approach to family caregivers
Family members of a person with dementia are often the “hidden patients” in the room. Primary caregivers – spouses, children, or others – are subject to enormous physical and emotional strain over time [4]. They administer medications, help with bathing, dressing, and feeding, monitor safety, arrange medical visits – all while giving up parts of their personal lives. Studies indicate severe psychological consequences for family members who provide care., including higher rates of depression, anxiety, and burnout compared to the general population [4]. It is important that general health care providers recognize this and adopt a Family-centered in treatment
Some principles for supporting family caregivers:
- Recognize family members as part of treatment: Family members They are not marginal guests. Rather, it is a central component of patient care. During a clinic visit, they were asked questions such as “How are you doing?” or “How can we help you?” A practical example is presented in a dilemma published in the AMA Journal of Ethics: A physician noticed that the caregiver’s spouse seemed exhausted and gently asked how she was doing, which led to her being overwhelmed and receiving assistance [4]. A simple act of interest and empathy can give the caregiver the feeling that they are not alone. Research by Gitlin and Hodgson (2016) suggests that in such circumstances, the physician should Provide the therapist with support, encouragement, and education – not only out of concern for the therapist himself, but also because his well-being directly affects the well-being of the patient [4].
- Legitimize their feelings and offer a listening ear.: Family caregivers may experience feelings of guilt, anger, grief (over the loss of the person they once knew), and sometimes a sense of helplessness. Acknowledge these feelings. For example, you might say: “I understand that this is very difficult. It is natural to feel exhausted and frustrated sometimes.” Simple empathy This, without judgment, can bring significant emotional relief. Encourage them to ask questions about their loved one's condition, and take the time to explain in clear terms the course of the disease, the expected symptoms, and ways to cope.
- Practical guidance and support resources: A doctor who is not a dementia specialist can still direct the family to sources of help. For example, refer them to support groups for dementia caregivers in the community, to non-profit organizations (such as the EMDA Association in Israel), and to welfare and health services that can help (such as a home caregiver for a few hours a week to provide respite for the primary caregiver). Psycho-educational interventions For caregivers, it has been proven effective: A famous study in New York showed that a structured counseling and support program for caregiver spouses not only improved their mood, but also Delayed the time until the patient was hospitalized in a nursing home by an average of almost a year [5]. That is, providing tools and support to caregivers allows a family member to continue to care for the person at home for longer. Recent studies also indicate that when the caregiver feels supported and knowledgeable, quality of life improves. His and the patient's Improves, and the need for emergency interventions decreases.
- Involving the family in treatment planning and medical decisions: Be sure to involve family members in decisions – both the easy ones (such as creating a routine at home) and the difficult ones (such as end-of-life decisions). This will empower them and increase cooperation. The family-centered care model The patient's well-being also depends on the well-being of the family [4]. For example, before starting a new medication or referring for tests, discuss practical options and preferences with the family, and explain the considerations. Such sharing, along with respecting the family's intuitive knowledge of the patient, leads to more realistic treatment plans and their better implementation.
Finally, encourage primary caregivers to take care of themselves as well – go for regular checkups, rest when they can, and know that they are allowed to ask for help. Your family doctor can help “take care of the caregiver” by paying attention to signs of depression or exhaustion in the caregiver and referring them to appropriate support groups. Family members are your partners in care – treating them with empathy and respect is a direct investment in the patient’s health as well.
Cultural and multilingual sensitivity in the healthcare system
Israel is a diverse society, with patients and staff from different cultural and linguistic backgrounds. Compassionate care for a patient with dementia requires Sensitivity to cultural context of the patient and his family. Several highlights:
- Respecting values of dignity and privacy according to culture: A study conducted in Israel found that caregivers from the Arab sector demonstrated particularly high levels of humanity and compassion in treating elderly people with dementia, in part because they emphasized cultural values of Respect for the elderly and respect for their beliefs and privacy [6]. For example, they were careful to respect religious customs, ensure the privacy of the individual during personal care, and encourage the patient’s independence according to his or her ability – all from a cultural perception of respect for parents and elders. The results of the study showed that such care was More humane and respectful Compared to other cultural groups [6]. The conclusion for physicians is clear: learn about the patient's cultural background, and reflect this in treatment – for example, ask about his preferences regarding modesty during physical examination, adherence to kosher/halakhic food, prayer times, etc., and take this into account as much as possible.
- Adapting the language and communication approach: The language of communication with the patient is essential for his understanding and sense of security. In Israel, many of the elderly do not speak fluent Hebrew (for example, long-time immigrants from Russia, Ethiopia, or Holocaust survivors who speak Yiddish). Dementia may even cause a person to lose a language learned at a later age and return to their mother tongue. Therefore, Speak to the patient in a language they are comfortable with. – If you are not fluent, use a family member or medical interpreter when necessary. Communicating in your native language reduces anxiety and confusion. Also, be aware of cultural communication styles: some cultures have a tradition of family decision-making, or the elderly expect a very formal approach from the doctor. Adapt yourself – for example, with a patient of a certain ethnicity you may want to use a more formal title, while with others a warm and informal style will help. If you are unsure – Ask the family How the patient used to communicate and what he is comfortable with.
- Access to information and diagnoses – cultural sensitivity in truth: A sensitive issue is the degree of disclosure about the patient's condition. In some traditional societies, the family may request "Not telling dad he's sick, so as not to upset him."In contrast, in Western countries the prevailing approach is that the patient should be informed. Studies have shown that an almost absolute majority of patients Yes, we want to know their dementia diagnosis if asked [7], and that openly disclosing information does not usually cause irreversible psychological harm, especially when done sensitively and with hope [7]. Of course, the patient's cognitive ability to understand must be taken into account, but He should not be denied autonomy without reason.A doctor in Israel needs to gently mediate: explain to the family the importance of transparency and preparation for the future, while at the same time respecting their concerns. In some cases, it is possible to invite family members to a joint conversation in which the information is delivered gradually and with the emphasis on the message: "We are with you and it is possible to live with dementia, a life with meaning." In this way, both the patient's dignity and family cohesion are preserved.
- Harnessing beliefs and values as treatment enablers: On the positive side, be aware that religious beliefs and cultural values can be Source of strengthFor example, if it is known that the patient used to go to synagogue, encourage the family or social workers to help her continue to do so as much as possible – familiar rituals create a sense of calm and identity. If the patient speaks a particular language, music or songs from that culture can evoke fond memories. In a multicultural approach, the doctor also takes an interest in lifestyle habits (perhaps their favorite foods are related to their origin) and uses this to build rapport. Inclusive approach Such a plan, which takes into account the patient's background, creates trust and improves cooperation in treatment.
Dealing with challenging medical situations
During the care of people with dementia, doctors and medical teams encounter several common situations that require special sensitivity:
- Explaining a diagnosis or giving difficult news: When delivering a dementia diagnosis (or any other significant medical news), it is important to be honest but compassionate. Relaxed sitting, time allocated for conversation, and using simple but precise words are essential. It is recommended to say the word “dementia” or “Alzheimer’s” explicitly rather than hiding behind vague phrases like “some memory problems,” as ambiguity can actually increase anxiety [7]. Research has shown that doctors sometimes tend to oversimplify the truth, but in practice most patients and their families prefer to know the diagnosis clearly and simply [7]. However, the disclosure of the diagnosis must be accompanied by a message of support and hope.: Immediately after providing the information, it is important to go over and discuss the treatment plan – whether it is medication, lifestyle changes, support services or cognitive rehabilitation programs [7]. For example, you could say: “You have early-stage Alzheimer’s. This means that there will be memory difficulties that will increase. But we are here to help – there are medications that can slow the decline a little, and it is important that we focus on exercise and nutrition, which will help the brain. We would also be happy to connect you with a support group to help you and your family cope.” Also important Emphasize what remains, not just what was lost. – Remind that despite limitations, people with dementia can live many years with a reasonable quality of life, with moments of joy and meaning [7]. Sufficient time should be devoted to such a conversation; it is not a conversation that is suitable for “5 minutes at the end of the appointment” [7]. The study recommended allocating longer, dedicated appointments for delivering a diagnosis, and even inviting the patient and their family for a return appointment within a few days to answer additional questions after they have been given time to digest the information.
- Physical examinations and medical procedures: A person with dementia may resist physical exams or procedures (such as blood tests, X-rays) out of fear, confusion, or lack of understanding of what is going to happen. To overcome this, Explain each step simply before and during the testFor example: "Now I'm going to listen to your lungs with the stethoscope - it might be a little cold, but it won't hurt" and then: "Great, thank you, now just blood pressure and I'm done." Studies have found that giving Step-by-step instructions And in a milder form, it reduces anxiety and resistance in patients with dementia [2]. Obtaining consent and empowering the patient: Even if the patient has cognitive decline, approach them with a request for permission (“Can I check your abdomen now?”) and wait for verbal or nonverbal consent (such as a nod). Providing a sense of control, even through a small choice (“Do you want to sit in the chair or lie in bed during the examination?”), can reduce resistance by making the patient an active participant [2]. In addition, Integrate family members During the test: The presence of a familiar person who holds your hand and explains can also be calming. Family members also sometimes know "tricks" from experience - perhaps the patient's favorite music in the background distracts him during a blood test, or if you give him a favorite object to hold, it calms him down. Collaborate with the family to discover these ways.
- Resistance to treatment or medication: There may be situations where the patient refuses to take medication or be hospitalized despite a medical need. Instead of confronting him directly, Try to find out what the source of the resistance is.. Often there is an underlying reason – fear of side effects, a bad experience in the past, or simply confusion and lack of understanding. Talk quietly, try to reflect: “I see you don’t want to take the pills. Is it because you’re afraid they’ll make you feel bad?” – His answer, even partial, will give you a clue. Allow him to ask questions, and answer honestly. Using the principle of "diversion and return"": If there is no immediate urgency, try to move on to another topic to calm the situation, and try the medical procedure again after a few minutes. For example, if they refuse to take their temperature, put down the thermometer, talk about something calming (a favorite topic), and after a moment offer it again. This tactic – stopping when resistance is encountered and trying again later – is supported by evidence as an effective strategy instead of direct confrontation [2]. In extreme cases where there is an urgent need for treatment that the patient is refusing (e.g., life-saving treatment), mild sedation or protective measures may be necessary, but these Last resort And only after the subtle ways have been exhausted.
- Managing challenging behavior: People with mid-to-late stage dementia may exhibit behaviors such as repetitiveness, wandering, verbal or physical aggression, and refusal of care. It is important to remember that these behaviors are often a form of communication of an unmet need. or distress, and not the patient's "bad character" [1]. For example, a patient who shouts and curses while taking a shower - perhaps the water is too cold for him or he is embarrassed to be showered. Therefore, the correct approach is An investigative and empathetic approach: Check for and address sources of discomfort (pain, hunger, need to use the bathroom, noisy, unfamiliar, or threatening environments) rather than reacting with anger or punishment. Research supports the "Needs-driven dementia behavior" approach, which holds that challenging behavior is the result of unmet needs or a mismatch between the environment and the patient's limitations [1]. As mentioned, calm communication, distraction, humor, and finding meaning For the patient (for example, letting him hold a familiar object or engage in a simple action that he is capable of) – all of these can reduce problematic behavior more than any medication.
Summary: The importance of compassion in dealing with the consequences of dementia
Dementia is a disease that affects not only memory, but also All walks of life of the patient and his family – psychologically, socially and physically. For the patient, cognitive decline leads to confusion, loss of independence and sometimes a low sense of self-worth. For family members, it is a continuous grieving process for the loss of the person they knew, along with the burden of daily care. In such a situation, the compassionate and empathetic approach of the medical team is not a “luxury” but a necessary condition for successful treatment. Studies have shown that a personalized, person-centered approach, combining understanding, respect, and partnership with the patient, not only improves the treatment experience but also makes a real contribution to health. – for example, by reducing symptoms of depression and irritability and improving quality of life [8]. For the family, supportive guidance from the medical establishment also reduces feelings of loneliness and burnout.
In the story we opened with, Dr. Liora sensitively managed to establish communication with Nurit and relieve Yael. It may be a small moment, but moments like these add up to a different approach to treatment – an approach that sees the humanity behind the disease. In dementia medicine, technology and medications are not enough; a big heart, patience and flexibility are required . Using relatively simple tools – eye contact, a kind word, a clear explanation, real listening – any doctor, even without a specialization in geriatrics, can make a big difference in the well-being of patients with dementia and their families. A compassionate approach is the key to reducing suffering, preserving the patient’s dignity and building a true partnership with their family, in order to more easily cope with the challenges of the disease. This is the heart of human medicine, and with the evidence base described – it is clear that science also supports it. Let us always remember: treating a person with dementia means treating their heart and soul, and no less so – the hearts of those close to them.
If you need free advice, information and telephone support, contact the EMDA hotline – the Israeli Association for Dementia, Alzheimer's and Similar Diseases, at *8889.
bibliography
- Collins, R., Hunt, A., Quinn, C., Martyr, A., Pentecost, C., & Clare, L. (2022). Methods and approaches for enhancing communication with people with moderate-to-severe dementia that can facilitate their inclusion in research and service evaluation: Findings from the IDEAL program. Dementia, 21(4), 1135–1153.
- Sunjaya, AM, Schreiber, T., Kantilal, K., Davies, N., & Griffiths, S. (2025). Communication strategies for delivering personalized dementia care and support: A mixed-methods systematic review and narrative synthesis. Age and Aging, 54(5), afaf120.
- Proper communication for home care » Alzheimer's Center – Alzheimer's Medical Center
- Gitlin, LN, & Hodgson, NA (2016). Who should assess the needs of and care for a dementia patient's caregiver? AMA Journal of Ethics, 18(12), 1171–1181.
- Mittelman, MS, Ferris, SH, Shulman, E., Steinberg, G., & Levin, B. (1996). A family intervention to delay nursing home placement of patients with Alzheimer's disease: A randomized controlled trial. JAMA, 276(21), 1725–1731. https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/8940320
- Siegel-Itzkovich, J (2015). Study shows Arab caregivers lead in compassion, humanity. The Jerusalem Post, December 9, 2015.
- Briggs, R., & Kennelly, S. (2017). Dementia: Disclosing the diagnosis. Age-related Health Care Department, Tallaght Hospital, October 11, 2017.
- Kim, S.K., & Park, M. (2017). Effectiveness of person-centered care on people with dementia: A systematic review and meta-analysis. Clinical Interventions in Aging, 12, 381–397.
Dr. Nati Blum She is the CEO. EMDA Association and holds a PhD in Psychology from the University of Sacramento. Her doctoral dissertation focused on face-to-face group therapy versus virtual group therapy. In her role at EMDA, she harnesses her professional and managerial experience to lead efforts to improve the quality of life of those dealing with dementia, promote their rights, and raise public awareness of the phenomenon in Israel.